Light Versus Heavy, the Debate Continues!

Dec 16, 2022

What is the ideal weight for a hunting rifle?

The argument of LIGHT V/S HEAVY in hunting rifles is alive and well around the campfire. For those of you who own a HOLLAND SIGNATURE SERIES RIFLE, you know that I do not build fly-weight rifles. YES, I understand they are a pleasure to carry in the field, but, IMHO that is about where it ends. Having a bit of weight in a rifle can be quite advantageous when the moment of truth arrives. After all, why do we carry a rifle? When game is spotted the idea is to kill it as quickly and humanely as possible. Heavier rifles seem to do the job a bit better, as the shooter will/can shoot them better in the field. For example, a lightweight rifle can be more difficult to hold steady when you are winded; light rifles recoil more, making the shooter more susceptible to flinching; table manners behind a light rifle are much more critical, and demand utter perfection when making long shots. Lastly, pencil-weight barrels often heat up quickly and point-of-impact moves considerably from shot to shot due to stress in the barrel. Years back, I had a student with a famous maker rifle and a pencil barrel in 300 Weatherby, between the recoil and point-of-impact shift, he had a hard time keeping 3 shots on a piece of paper. Lovely to carry, but difficult to hit anything with.


What is an ideal weight you may ask? Using today's technology, stocks, barrels, mounts, scopes etc. a finished weight no less than 8.5-9.0 lbs should be considered. Adding an additional 1-2 pounds is not a bad idea either. Most of my personal hunting rifles are 10 plus pounds and I've lugged them all over the world from sea level to 10,000 feet. When it came time to shoot, I NEVER REGRETTED HAVING A HEAVY RIFLE!


Taking a step back in time, early buffalo hunters carried heavy rifles, 15 plus pounds were not uncommon. Take your dad's old Mauser, Springfield, or Eddystone rifle from the 1950s and put it on the scale. Whelen, O'Connor, Keith, Bell, Page, Selous, and Roosevelt carried wood and steel in the field and never complained. Of course, this was an era without snowflakes. Add a few more ounces of protein to your diet and tote a heavier rifle. When game is spotted the results will be to your liking, don't forget to SMILE in the photo!

16 Dec, 2022
My hunting partner and I have kicked this idea around for quite some time, and it has serious merit. I get to shaking my head at the long-drawn-out communication that often occurs between spotters and shooters. Not only is the dialog long, but it is also confusing to the shooter and poor performance in the field is pretty much guaranteed! When Ernie Bishop and I shot the WTRC shoot in Wyoming, we had great dialog and our performance was evident, taking 2nd place two years in a row at this difficult cross-country shoot. But, as the saying goes: "THERE is ALWAYS room for IMPROVEMENT." So, grab a cold one from the fridge and listen up! For those of you who have been to my shooting school, you will remember the SHOOTER READY, SPOTTER READY technique that we teach. It works pretty well and is easy enough to teach. However, it takes most students a couple of days to get it down. They always want to ADD UNNECESSARY WORDS to the dialog: Boy Jonas, that was really close, I'd just come over a bit more and let's try-er again. You'll git-er this time. Aaarg! The dialog does nothing for the shooter, it wastes time, and is confusing as hell! What's close? How much is a bit more? Am I out vertically or horizontally? You get the picture! The NEW SYSTEM we've developed is far simpler and very concise. ( As the KIWI's would say) Let's have a "GO" at it. Let's begin by identifying the players. The Spotter is called ALPHA, the Shooter is called BRAVO, Hold is called CHARLIE and DELTA is the word for FIRE. Using the phonetic alphabet makes it very simple; there are no confusing words that interrupt the shooting sequence. Once the target is identified (more on this in another article) the spotter calls out ALPHA; when the shooter is on the target he calls BRAVO. Both spotter and shooter are now on target. The spotter's job is to call the wind and let the shooter know when to fire. CHARLIE is the word for "HOLD," and as the desired wind approaches he can say CHARLIE CHARLIE (prepping the shooter to get ready). When the wind is perfect DELTA is uttered and the shooter FIRES. Here it is in real-time: ALPHA... BRAVO... CHARLIE... CHARLIE-CHARLIE...DELTA! Upon impact, the spotter simply calls the correction NEEDED to hit the "X", not the amount the shooter missed by. There should be NO confusion as to what needs to be put in the rifle. UP/DOWN 2-MOA, LEFT/RIGHT .5 MOA. Always call the correction in MINUTES or a FRACTION of a MINUTE. There is a bit of leeway here in how the correction can be done. The shooter remains on the rifle after firing the shot and CYCLES THE BOLT. When he is back on target he calls BRAVO (letting the spotter know he has acquired the target and is ready for any necessary correction, or whether it is necessary to shoot again). The spotter should know the "CLICK VALUE" of the shooter's scope (i.e., .250 or .5 MOA, or whatever?). He can call the correction in MINUTES (allowing the shooter to do the math, converting minutes to "clicks") Or, the spotter can do the MATH and the shooter just counts/feels the tactile clicks in his/her scope to make the required correction. The latter is the better choice IMHO. While keeping the target in the scope, the shooter feels the "tactile clicks" and repeats the correction back to the spotter. Keep in mind the shooter stays on target and SHOULD KNOW the direction (clockwise/counterclockwise) his/her dials turn to elevate and adjust wind without breaking stock weld to look at the dials.
16 Dec, 2022
Determining your Cleaning Interval
By Mandi davenport 16 Dec, 2022
16 Dec, 2022
How to take proper caution when dealing with a four-legged critter that can send you to the pearly gates.
16 Dec, 2022
Take a minute to watch the proper method to deploy your bi-pod in the field
Do you need a Magnum
16 Dec, 2022
As a custom rifle builder, I get dozens of calls a month with individuals wanting me to build them the latest wonder-magnum featured on the cover of some gun rag. Typically it’s some gun scribe who is extolling the virtues of the new cartridge and how it kills more effectively than present-day choices. Bull elk, distant mule deer, and far-away exotics don’t stand a chance when shot with this wicked new development. Blistering muzzle velocities, zero hold-over to the next zip code coupled with BC approaching .999.
16 Dec, 2022
Hunting in the snow has its challenges and here are a few tips to keep in mind...
16 Dec, 2022
Taking dangerous game seriously...
By Mike Curtis 17 Sep, 2020
by David Bryer Hawaii is a popular vacation destination, and many have been fortunate to have xperienced one, or all the islands through big game fishing, snorkeling, diving, sunset cruise, sunbathing, kayaking and so many other adventures. With a multitude of choices, people don’t think to research the hunting opportunities available. My wife and I […]
By Mike Curtis 10 Jan, 2020
6:00 – 8:30 pm Friday, January 31st at the Elks Lodge934 Lewis Ave. in Billings Enjoy cocktails and appetizers while learning about some of SCI’s premier professional outfitters.
More Posts
Share by: